Elle Women's Sweatshirt, Collegiate Golf Green - Ellsworth + Ivey Sweaters | Maisonette: Complete Review

Ellsworth + Ivey — Elle Women’s Sweatshirt, Collegiate Golf Green — Review: Worth it? Best for Casual & Preppy Wardrobes

Looking for a midweight crew that reads classic but feels fresh? If your closet needs a relaxed, slightly boxy sweater with a sporty, preppy vibe, the Elle Women’s Sweatshirt from Ellsworth + Ivey aims squarely at that gap. In this review I break down material, real-world wear, fit, and how it stacks up against similar options so you can decide: is it worth the $98 price tag?

Why consider this sweater?

• Boxy, “boyfriend” silhouette that layers easily over tees and shirts.
• Contrasting neckline and stripe detail for a collegiate, casual look.
• Midweight blend (cotton/nylon/wool) that promises softness with structure.

Material & Quality

Real-world Experience — Pros & Cons

Pros

• Comfortable drape: The cotton-heavy blend feels soft against the skin but the nylon adds structure so the sweater keeps its boxy silhouette instead of slouching into shapelessness.
• Light warmth: The 10% wool gives extra insulation without making the piece too heavy — great for cool spring/fall days or layered winter looks.
• Effortlessly styled: The contrasting neckline and stripe details read modern-preppy — pairs nicely with denim, chinos, or tailored shorts for a weekend look.
• Easy care for everyday use: It’s forgiving — not ultra-delicate like pure cashmere, so it holds up better to regular wear when treated properly.

Cons

• Pilling potential: Any blend with wool may show light pilling over time, especially in high-friction areas like under the arms or where a bag strap sits.
• Not a heavy winter layer: If you want true thermal warmth, this won’t replace a thick wool or a down-lined piece.
• Fit is intentionally boxy: If you prefer fitted or tailored sweaters, the silhouette may feel too oversized.
• Made in China: For shoppers prioritizing artisan or local manufacturing, this may be a consideration.

Fit & Sizing

The sweater is described as boxy with a “boyfriend” look. If you like a roomy, relaxed fit, choose your normal size. If you want a slightly less oversized silhouette, consider sizing down. Available sizes range from XS to XL — expect about the same roominess across sizes because of the intended cut.

Quick Comparison: How it stacks up

Versus J.Crew Cotton-Cashmere Crewneck (similar price tier)

• J.Crew’s cotton-cashmere feels plusher thanks to cashmere; it’s softer at first wear but requires more delicate care.
• Ellsworth + Ivey’s nylon content gives the Elle more structure and longevity in shape; it’s a bit more casual and sporty in styling.
• Both land in a comparable price band, but choice depends on whether you prioritize luxurious hand (J.Crew) or a structured, modern silhouette (Ellsworth + Ivey).

Versus Everlane Organic Cotton Crew (more budget-friendly)

• Everlane typically uses heavier organic cotton and leans minimalist; it’s a great basic at a lower price point.
• Elle brings additional interest with stripes and a contrasting neckline plus the light wool for warmth — a better option if you want a statement casual knit rather than a plain staple.

Who should buy this?

• Best for: People who want a relaxed, preppy/collegiate look that layers well — think weekend wear, coffee runs, casual offices.
• Good for: Those who prefer midweight sweaters that keep structure and want a design detail (stripe & contrast neckline) to lift outfits.
• Not for: Shoppers looking for fitted knits, heavy winter insulation, or pure luxury fibers like high-end cashmere.

Short take: A dependable, stylish midweight crew that reads modern-preppy — comfortable, structured, and an easy reach at $98 if you want casual polish without the cashmere price.

Verdict — Worth it?

If you want a lively, wearable crew with a boxy silhouette and a touch of warmth, the Elle Women’s Sweatshirt is worth considering. At $98 it competes well: it’s not a luxury knit, but it’s a thoughtfully composed everyday piece with practical durability. For a shopper who favors casual preppy style, this delivers strong value.

Call to Action

If you’re ready to try it, remember there’s a New Customer Offer: 10% Off $75+ with code NEW10 when applicable through participating retailers. The Elle Sweatshirt already qualifies for free shipping eligibility on many sellers — check size availability (XS–XL) and consider ordering a size down if you prefer a less boxy fit.

Final notes

• Price: $98
• Material: 60% Cotton / 30% Nylon / 10% Wool
• Made in: China
• Styling tip: Wear over a slim button-down or with high-waisted denim and white sneakers for a classic, modern-prep outfit.